A Singaporean court has granted bail to three men suspected of smuggling Nvidia server computers, potentially containing chips affected by US export rules, to organizations in China. The move comes nearly two weeks after the men were charged with fraud and smuggling, allegedly misrepresenting the destination of the servers to suppliers Dell and Super Micro.
The case involves servers provided by Singaporean companies, which were then moved to Malaysia, with transactions totaling around $390 million. It is unclear what the final destination of the servers would be, but prosecutors suspect they were intended for China. The three men, including two Singaporean nationals and a Chinese national, were charged with fraud and smuggling, and face potential imprisonment and fines if convicted.
The bail amounts were set at S$800,000 ($600,000) and S$600,000 each for the two Singaporean men, while the Chinese national's bail was set at S$1 million. The next court hearing is scheduled for May 2. The prosecution has requested an eight-week delay to complete investigations and has asked for specific conditions, including barring the men from airports or border checkpoints and prohibiting them from discussing the case if they are released on bail.
The Chinese national, in particular, has been ordered to wear an electronic monitoring device. The case has sparked concerns around the export of sensitive technology, particularly in the context of AI development. Nvidia's chips are used in AI applications, and the company has been at the center of controversy around the export of its technology to China.
In fact, according to Nvidia's latest annual report, Singapore accounted for 18% of revenue in the fiscal year that ended on January 28, despite shipments to the country making up less than 2% of sales. This has raised questions around the company's supply chain and the potential for its technology to be diverted to restricted countries.
The case also highlights the growing importance of Southeast Asia in the global technology supply chain. Malaysia, in particular, has been implicated in the fraud case, with the country's government stating that it would take "necessary action" against Malaysian companies involved in the alleged transfer of Nvidia chips from Singapore to China.
The incident has also drawn attention to China's DeepSeek, an AI company that has gained global recognition for its advanced technology and cost-effective solutions. DeepSeek's AI is powered by Nvidia's chips, despite efforts to restrict exports and prevent the technology from being used in China. The case has sparked concerns around the potential for restricted technology to be diverted to China, and the implications for global AI development.
As the case unfolds, it is likely to have significant implications for the technology industry, particularly around export restrictions and the supply chain for sensitive technology. The incident has also highlighted the need for greater transparency and accountability in the global technology supply chain.